News
Welcome to NeoRHDN! This place is still a work-in-progress, so pardon the construction...

Chat on Discord
Views: 721,239
Sections: Documents | Utilities | ROM Hacks | Games | Translations | Homebrew | Fonts | Community
Site: Main | Rules/FAQ | Discord | Memberlist | Latest posts | Stats | Ranks | Online users
11-12-24 10:42 PM
Guest: Register | Login

0 users currently in General Chat | 6 bots

Main - General Chat - What was the point of shutting down RHDN only to make a clone of it (1)


jamesamong007
Posted on 08-16-24 10:11 PM, in Link | ID: 197
Newcomer

Level: 3

Posts: 1/3
EXP: 48
Next: 80

Since: 08-16-24

Last post: 74 days
Last view: 74 days
Should have just kept the original site up and running or at just say you were moving to a new server/host for future hacks. Waste of time, attention and internet space.

The Gobbler
Posted on 08-16-24 10:18 PM, in Link | ID: 198
Root Administrator

Red Koopa

Level: 15

Posts: 47/124
EXP: 13301
Next: 3083

Since: 08-12-24

Last post: 18 days
Last view: 16 days
That's something you'd have to take up with Nightcrawler; this new site is made without Nightcrawler's involvement

Check out some of my websites!
imageimageimage

ShinobiWannabe
Posted on 08-17-24 12:40 AM, in Link | ID: 204
Newcomer

Level: 1

Posts: 1/1
EXP: 9
Next: 2

Since: 08-17-24

Last post: 87 days
Last view: 87 days
jamesamong007, old site is being destroyed by the old admin Nightcrawler.

MacUser
Posted on 08-22-24 05:06 AM, in Link | ID: 357

Shyguy

Level: 12

Posts: 14/90
EXP: 7780
Next: 141

Since: 08-21-24

Last post: 4 days
Last view: 22 hours
This is the better RHDN.

____________________
8-bit is enough.

voliol
Posted on 08-22-24 07:12 AM, in Link | ID: 362

Goomba

Level: 6

Posts: 7/20
EXP: 824
Next: 83

Since: 08-19-24

Last post: 10 days
Last view: 10 days
Due to complications (don't remember the details), RHDN is being discontinued. Thankfully, its database has been archived/put up for use, so various sites are scrambling to become the successor. This site is one of those, and imho the nicest looking of the contenders.

____________________
Developer of the Universal Pokémon Randomizer FVX, dabbling Dragon Quest VI hacker

Gi Nattak
Posted on 08-29-24 07:47 PM, in Link | ID: 568
Newcomer

Level: 1

Posts: 1/1
EXP: 9
Next: 2

Since: 08-14-24
From: Cali

Last post: 75 days
Last view: 21 days
I do hope there's just one successor when all's said and done, it'd be a pain to have to check for and update or submit hacks on multiple predominant romhacking sites that host them instead of just one like it was with RHDN. Last I checked the RHDN Discord staff was going to attempt to make a new site also, but neoromhacking already seems a fair bit ahead of it... If both sites decide to not concede though I suppose we will have more than one!

MacUser
Posted on 08-29-24 08:54 PM, in Link | ID: 571

Shyguy

Level: 12

Posts: 41/90
EXP: 7780
Next: 141

Since: 08-21-24

Last post: 4 days
Last view: 22 hours
Posted by Gi Nattak
I do hope there's just one successor when all's said and done, it'd be a pain to have to check for and update or submit hacks on multiple predominant romhacking sites that host them instead of just one like it was with RHDN. Last I checked the RHDN Discord staff was going to attempt to make a new site also, but neoromhacking already seems a fair bit ahead of it... If both sites decide to not concede though I suppose we will have more than one!


Well there is a rom hack site just for Super Mario World hacks. It's got a handful of Yoshi's Island rom hacks on it but it's like 98% Super Mario World stuff. There's some fun hacks there that aren't on this site. It's been around a long time too. My personal favorite one is "Mario is Missing Done Right".

____________________
8-bit is enough.

The Evil Vampony
Posted on 08-29-24 09:19 PM, in Link | ID: 572

Shyguy

Level: 12

Posts: 22/83
EXP: 7091
Next: 830

Since: 08-16-24
From: MY MOM!

Last post: 1 day
Last view: 1 day
Posted by MacUser
Posted by Gi Nattak
I do hope there's just one successor when all's said and done, it'd be a pain to have to check for and update or submit hacks on multiple predominant romhacking sites that host them instead of just one like it was with RHDN. Last I checked the RHDN Discord staff was going to attempt to make a new site also, but neoromhacking already seems a fair bit ahead of it... If both sites decide to not concede though I suppose we will have more than one!


Well there is a rom hack site just for Super Mario World hacks. It's got a handful of Yoshi's Island rom hacks on it but it's like 98% Super Mario World stuff. There's some fun hacks there that aren't on this site. It's been around a long time too. My personal favorite one is "Mario is Missing Done Right".

There is a lot of ROM hacking sites for specific games or franchises already, so I wouldn't worry about it. I think people who like a general "one stop shop" style site like RHDN was just don't want to have to go to both neoromhacking.net and romhack.ing to find new stuff.

____________________
Build a man a fire, and he's warm for a night. Set a man on fire, and he's warm for the rest of his life.

voliol
Posted on 08-30-24 08:47 AM, in Link | ID: 579

Goomba

Level: 6

Posts: 17/20
EXP: 824
Next: 83

Since: 08-19-24

Last post: 10 days
Last view: 10 days
Having a general site for "hacks" also helps with all those games that don't have a thriving ROM hacking community, all those myriad translations of RPGs with no place to go on the anglophone internet because before said translation only a handful people have ever heard of the game.

Now do I hope we only end up with one generalist site, because having to search through a number of them to find a ROM is a pain, but we can't expect the one true successor to be apparent quite yet. As much as I hope it will be NeoRHDN rather than RHDI - some whitespace is welcome on a website, but being able to see only two (2) games listed on the search screen at once, on desktop (!), is not.

____________________
Developer of the Universal Pokémon Randomizer FVX, dabbling Dragon Quest VI hacker

Galeforce
Posted on 09-15-24 09:37 PM, in (rev. 2 of 09-16-24 01:20 AM by Galeforce) Link | ID: 844

Paragoomba

Level: 11

Posts: 11/74
EXP: 4885
Next: 1100

Since: 09-15-24
From: Somewhere

Last post: 14 hours
Last view: 2 hours
I have to remind that while there are many games with a thriving romhacking community, there's equally as many games that aren't so lucky. Which is why it is especially important that there's a main hub that can give attention to these less fortunate games, because they have their own dedicated fanbase, no matter how big or how small they are.

I hope to see this site thrive, and carry on the legacy inherited from RHDN.

yharnam
Posted on 10-21-24 09:52 PM, in Link | ID: 1182
Newcomer

Level: 2

Posts: 3/3
EXP: 26
Next: 20

Since: 10-16-24

Last post: 22 days
Last view: 5 days
Centralization is dangerous, the web is at its best when there are multiple smaller sources of data/information. It's more convenient when things are centralized, but it isn't so inconvenient to have multiple sources that it's worth the downsides to centralize. There's never just one Italian restaurant in a city, right? There are multiple options, each doing things a bit differently, etc.


Wessmess99
Posted on 10-22-24 06:44 AM, in (rev. 3 of 10-22-24 06:50 AM by Wessmess99) Link | ID: 1183

Struttin' On In

Level: 1

Posts: 1/1
EXP: 9
Next: 2

Since: 08-16-24

Last post: 21 days
Last view: 7 days
Posted by yharnam
Centralization is dangerous, the web is at its best when there are multiple smaller sources of data/information. It's more convenient when things are centralized, but it isn't so inconvenient to have multiple sources that it's worth the downsides to centralize. There's never just one Italian restaurant in a city, right? There are multiple options, each doing things a bit differently, etc.

I strongly disagree. Galeforce sums up my thoughts on the matter perfectly. Without a centralized site, so many hacks and translations would get lost in the pasta sauce of the many "Italian restaurants".

thingsiplay
Posted on 10-22-24 01:29 PM, in (rev. 2 of 10-22-24 01:31 PM by thingsiplay) Link | ID: 1184

Unprofessional
Level: 10

Posts: 40/56
EXP: 3749
Next: 665

Since: 08-24-24
From: Germany

Last post: 3 days
Last view: 4 hours
I actually agree with both sides: centralized and decentralized. There are pros and cons to both sides. Centralized has the problem of being controlled by a single or few entities, which they can do whatever they want. On the other side a central place is easier to use and maintain for end users, as only one source needs to be checked and maintained. In example I don't have to look for 3 sources to know which version is the newest one of keep up where does what get uploaded.

Downsides are the opposite of those points off course. Each community has its own rules and members. The usability is different and so on. You have to check discussions in different forums, because maybe someone helps with a solution in one community that another one needs help with. Solutions and requests are scattered.

Therefore I am conflicted with this question.

AutumnShinespark
Posted on 10-22-24 05:19 PM, in Link | ID: 1185

Bronto Burt

Level: 7

Posts: 27/28
EXP: 1407
Next: 41

Since: 08-14-24

Last post: 17 days
Last view: 4 hours
Well, when it was just one place I was more inclined to push out quick updates. But now even if I could update on RHDN again, so many people have my latest public version that I need a way to let them know there's an update. It's not like Super Nintendo games have an auto update feature, and I have no way of knowing how many people actually read my readme to know about the Discord for update discussion.

At this point I'll end up passively notifying people of updates by making the old version incompatible on RetroAchievements and putting a link to the current version in the game's comment section. It's a pain, but I have some other work to finish before getting to that point. So I've been putting off the debate on how many places to host updates.

____________________
If you need me, I'll be overanalyzing how games work. Y'know, instead of playing them.

The Evil Vampony
Posted on 10-25-24 02:17 PM, in Link | ID: 1204

Shyguy

Level: 12

Posts: 71/83
EXP: 7091
Next: 830

Since: 08-16-24
From: MY MOM!

Last post: 1 day
Last view: 1 day
Posted by yharnam
Centralization is dangerous, the web is at its best when there are multiple smaller sources of data/information. It's more convenient when things are centralized, but it isn't so inconvenient to have multiple sources that it's worth the downsides to centralize. There's never just one Italian restaurant in a city, right? There are multiple options, each doing things a bit differently, etc.
I'll second agreeing that Galeforce said what I think already, but let me put it another way.



A generalized resource greatly helps out the games and communities not big or popular enough for someone to step up and make a community dedicated to it, but it doesn't stop others from making such dedicated spaces, and with the RHDN fiasco as it has been, there are even more choices between generalized "one-stop-shop" replacements for RHDN than there ever has been. The good ones will prevail (hopefully), and the bad ones will eventually wither away or something, all in time, but for now there's more options than ever. I don't think it could be any more decentralized right now.

____________________
Build a man a fire, and he's warm for a night. Set a man on fire, and he's warm for the rest of his life.

Main - General Chat - What was the point of shutting down RHDN only to make a clone of it (1)

Affiliates:


Acmlmboard v2.5.6+neo (2024-08-13)
© 2005-2024 Acmlm, Emuz, NinCollin, et al.

Page rendered in 0.117 seconds. (923KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 101, rows: 470/478, time: 0.099 seconds.